Belgrade Philharmonic Orchestra
performing in Goša factory,
March 5th, 1963
(courtesy of Belgrade
Philharmonic Orchestra)

Notes on the “Goša” Photograph

Looking at the photograph of the philharmonic concert in front of the “Goša” factory workers today, one is tempted to recognize the practice it depicts as a radical gesture that aimed not only at the democratization of the cultural field but also at the profound transformation of the overall social relations. In certain aspects, and especially when observed from today’s perspective of ever greater deprivation in labor rights and precarious working conditions, it certainly has been, furthermore, since this was not an isolated event. This practice was rather widespread for a time, while this same orchestra, for example, held a similar concert in the same factory ten years earlier.

However, this practice of bringing high art among the workers, which was introduced as one of the ways towards the essential democratization of arts and culture, was facing some serious and well-funded critique in its own time. For example, curator Dunja Blažević referred to it as “pure demagogy,” which was reflected in “bringing the philharmonic orchestras to the factory so that tired and hungry workers could listen to the 5th Symphony in the factory hall after their long working hours.” (kuda.org, SCCA/pro.ba, WHW 2010, 161)[1]  One can see an illustration of such a view in the depiction of “hungry and tired workers” while listening to Beethoven’s 9th Symphony (the very same one played in front of the “Goša” workers) in one of the seminal Yugoslav movies from the 1960s, Dušan Makavejev’s Čovek nije ‘tica (Man is Not a Bird).

This type of critique, however, was not coming only from the representatives of the New Art Practice or the so-called Black wave in cinema, but also from the cultural workers and theorists that were closer to the official state policies. Many saw it as a failure of the Yugoslav socialism to create conditions for everyone to participate equally in cultural life and enjoy high art in theaters, concert halls, museums, and galleries rather than as a successful attempt at democratization – of arts and culture, but also of the overall society. Namely, according to some, even in the state of the workers, as Yugoslavia was self-defined and perceived, masses of workers stayed uneducated, financially deprived, “objects rather than subjects of culture,” those who were “created as cultural phenomena by others,” while themselves susceptible to mass culture of the lowest quality (Lukić 1974, 61).

Both the initial reaction at seeing the photograph from “Goša” and the critique of this specific approach to democratization of arts and culture make some of the important starting points in thinking about the ways of structuring the working process and translating The Chimneys on the Adriatic into the collaborative artwork in the present.

See: Segments from the Archives Considering Art Performances in the Factory Halls

[1] Instead, Blažević and her colleagues, who back in the 1970s were gathered around the Student Cultural Center in Belgrade, advocated for the “correction of what was officially called ‘democratization of art and culture’… by opening and expanding the space for artistic practices while insisting on the interaction and inclusion of people in the creative process.” (kuda.org, SCCA/pro.ba, WHW 2010, 161)