
Art serves to add yet another layer of meaning to human existence. That’s something I’ve become convinced of when working directly with audiences. Very often, art quite literally adds another layer of meaning to a person’s life. Not beautifying it, but adding another layer of meaning. Because that, too, is one of the prejudices that we — cultural workers (or at least some of us) — hold onto, when we think that audiences want their lives to be made prettier. I haven’t encountered that. Audiences have no problem even with extremely demanding works of contemporary art, as long as they sense that it adds that meaning for them. But we very often push people away by refusing to reduce things to a simple measure that would be a common denominator or common factor of a given work — for me, for you, for a butcher’s shop worker, for a waitress, for anyone. I’m very aware that this might be hard to do, since someone who’s been in the profession for thirty years finds it very hard to believe, or even to think, that things could or should be done differently. But if all participants in that dialogue make the effort, then it’s absolutely possible. Because, of course, we can’t reduce all works of contemporary art or all concepts to a single word, but it might help if, for the purposes of at least an initial encounter with a given work or concept, we understood that it’s enough to first read a single layer. That not everything has to happen at once. That it’s okay to introduce someone to art the same way we’d introduce them into our own home: we know how we’ll welcome someone in the hallway and what we’ll say there, then what we’ll talk about in the living room, and what we’ll say as we see them out. I think it’s worth thinking about the communication of art in terms of some similar kind of circle. Because audiences respond well to exhibitions that have a very clear first layer of reading and understanding.
But instead, we introduce confusion. This year I encountered, perhaps, the largest number yet of artists who didn’t want their work to be communicated on any level beyond the title, and I found it to be rather shocking. Artists should be more aware of the fact that once a work enters an institutional, and especially a public, realm, it inevitably enters into communication, and that today, in the 21st century, it can hardly communicate through the mere fact of its presence, of simply being there. When a work enters an institution, that institution then has an obligation to demonstrate to society why that work is there. We have to make the effort to work in the public interest, and the public interest is for someone to understand, to learn, to come to love, to accept as their own, to understand why a cultural asset should exist — which is perhaps exactly what we’re missing today amid all this turmoil. The audience has a right to information and it’s our obligation to provide that, and far more broadly and extensively than simply providing them with a few words about the work. When we go to the doctor, we always complain that they didn’t give us enough information about our medical condition, or didn’t devote enough time to us, even though we pay for the healthcare system. But when we go into a museum or gallery — which we also pay for — we don’t complain that we didn’t learn anything about the work, even though we probably should start complaining. For me, these things are the same. That’s why I’m interested in whether our talk about this is merely declarative — whether we truly want the audience to participate, whether we really want to be equal, or whether we’ve just heard that this is trendy now, and so we act accordingly.
In many more instances, regular people, those who are not art-professionals, should be brought into certain decision-making processes within cultural institutions. I think that ordinary citizens are missing from culture, that culture is played out again and again by the same set of people. After all, until they have had enough of this kind of society, nothing at all will change. Just as, once, change wasn’t brought about by the political elite either, but by a huge number of fighters — first in war, and then fighters for an idea. Then, for a start, we would get a picture of what culture actually looks like in the society we live in. That picture would inevitably clash with the picture of “high culture” advocated by cultural workers, but at least we’d have a clear picture of where we stand. Starting from there, through some kind of educational project, we could develop the culture that’s actually needed. So we would have to find a way to involve people at some more primary level than the level of workshops, which is what we do now. That, for me, would be radical. It’s as if we’re losing the capacity to hear each other at all. We speak, yet we remain in our own positions. And in some instances we simply don’t want to include other people, knowing that we’ll be confronted with something that’s so different from us. Because — what if we, say, actually formed a gallery board that included a diverse range of people, that “ordinary person,” and then, in a gallery that exhibits contemporary art, that board decided that we should show slamarke — that is, works by women who make pictures using the technique of straw weaving. And how would I, as a professional, accept that? Yet I’m the one who invited them to make decisions. Would we then find ourselves facing something like — “we’ve put up with this long enough, now it’s your turn to listen to us”? But if we could create forums, rather than safe spaces, in which we could be brave together — then maybe something would come out of that. If we could create a joint space where there’s no fear to express what you truly think, or whether you’ll confront me with something that’s painful for me.
Because, for culture to be a field that makes it possible to think about change, it necessarily has to be participatory — it has to genuinely mean participation without restrictions. But at the same time, it also has to be very clearly value-oriented if it’s to contribute to any kind of social change. I can’t offer an answer here that would be any less radical. If we want a better society, we have to know what our values are. Just as we have to acknowledge that we don’t hold to the right values in the moment, either in culture or elsewhere. It’s a bit like the question of contemporary art — namely, the question of whether contemporary art is everything that is being made today, or whether it’s a value-based category? It is a value-based category; it isn’t everything that’s being made today. It’s the same with culture. If culture needs to be used to shape society, then — yes, we need to look, through participation, at where we stand, and yes, in some sense, through broader education, we need to arrive at the value-based aspects of culture that must be present. That would probably mean a terribly big cut and break, but then we would essentially return to that period from which the texts we’re discussing originate, which was also a huge cut and break from what preceded it. But without that kind of understanding of what’s required, I think we remain stuck in this limbo.
Still, I’m afraid that professionals in culture will find it hard to give up their positions, especially after this period in which we all feel shortchanged and deprived of our rights. Precisely when change does come, we’ll want more, and more, and more. It would be great if we wanted more participation, but I don’t think we’ll move in that direction, because that would require an enormously large shift in the consciousness of the entire society, and that doesn’t happen so simply.
Maybe what’s really needed is to turn some of our practices upside down. We’ve become terribly ossified in everything we do, anchored in those same daily routines. We should make a list of things we still haven’t done; do something we haven’t tried yet. But even for that list, we’d need someone we haven’t even invited, to tell us what we still haven’t done for them. That “something” is, at the same time, perhaps in terms of culture, pure utopia — because where in the world do people truly live within culture? Most of what passes for culture, everywhere in the world, is tourism, not genuine, lived coexistence with it. It’s something driven by the imperative of consumerism; like, if you haven’t been to the Prado, you haven’t seen Spain. That’s why I think this will remain a utopia. But if we stay within what is narrow — not even narrowly professional, but narrowly privileged — we will never reach any kind of mass inclusion.