
The workers’ culture, the culture of the proletarian revolution, is the provision of opportunities for every individual to become a creator to the extent that they feel compelled and are capable, however modestly, of communicating their creation to others for the benefit of society. If they can narrate stories, they should be able to gather an audience willing to listen; if they can paint, they should be able to put up an exhibition; if they have successfully advanced technology in their enterprise, they may rightfully expect social recognition (typically not financial) and to continue with similar undertakings; if they desire to play music, society should provide them freely with an instrument. […] Proletarian culture is neither bureaucratic moralizing nor managerial strategies; if it is a true historical innovation, it represents the unrestrained communication of the creative experiences of working people and the establishment of social conditions that enable the majority of working individuals to engage in creative pursuits.
In any case, aesthetics as such demonstrates that it no longer makes sense to separate high and amateur art, or something that may be perceived as profane from some kind of a sublime art. The imperative should be to bring people together; there should be neither a market nor a scene, but rather interaction between artists and open social critique should be enabled — because that is what both sides lack the most. Above all, they lack attention and material support. Today, institutions neglect amateurism or view it through elitist lenses, judging it to lack aesthetic value, while overlooking its critical potential and directness of its expression — even though it is certain that many people still wish to express themselves in this way. At the same time, both theorists and critics ignore amateurism since they cannot recognize any critical potential there.
Note, A.A.: Today, when the separation between amateurism and the sphere of professional art seems fully normalized, it is interesting to recall the words of writer Raša Popov written back in 1981: “This phenomenon of disunity, fragmentation, and the emergence of dominant groups that do not struggle on the principle of pluralism of interests but on the basis of hegemonic particularism, is an acute affliction on every political scene. In such a situation, culture is treated as a kind of social luxury, an instrument of social differentiation. People are divided into the culturally enlightened and the acculturated, the educated and the uneducated — which is absurd, because any humanistic enlightenment presupposes that every single person is entitled to culture … that culture is in fact the emanation of all people, not just gifted individuals. For humanists, talent is the ability to be human, not excellence in some isolated and artificially overdeveloped mental discipline. […] But there we can see yet another paradox. Shklovsky said that all the greatest spirits in world literature reached their highest achievements when expressing the being of the imperfect human. A good novel, drama, or poem speaks of an unsuccessful person. For Shklovsky, this is the fundamental law — the highest, deepest, most spiritual element in art. Great art moves us because it depicts a conductor who forgets the notes mid-concert, a merchant who is outwitted, a speaker who stutters… the most touching, deepest works of art are created about the imperfect human. The most spiritual creations arise as a cry of humanity, a slap in the face of the Übermensch, an expression of the untalented, worn-out human being! And yet, when we conduct cultural policy, we do the opposite: the main criterion is to deprive precisely those who play poorly, paint poorly, and speak poorly of economic support. This is a paradox and a rift between intuition and experience, not a triumph of reason.” (Popov 1981, 99–103)