
The emerging proletcult represents the most disastrous way to establish a new culture. It is not even a new culture but rather the tyranny of the mediocre, who, having occupied positions within the ruling apparatus, are able to elevate notions of social reasons, communicability, “being understandable by the masses,” and superficially understood social justice, marked by triviality, shallowness, and “realism.” However, while culture should be as accessible as bread, it must not be disseminated in that manner. Cultural equality cannot be achieved by simply enforcing intellectual leveling.
One should truly imagine a situation in which an exhibition is to be assembled from works brought in, say, by members of amateur clubs who are also workers. And let’s imagine that among these works — regardless of how technically skillful they may be — there are only landscapes, female nudes, sunsets, palm trees, cars: namely, all of the motifs that they already find appealing and hang on their locker doors. How, then, are we to think about any critical or social potential? Into what context should this be placed? This leads us to the question of emancipation and continuous education. Every amateur wants to improve, and as they develop technical skill, they can also advance theoretically. Amateurism is never fixed. Even these pastoral works, which reflect their interests or develop certain skills, must be situated within the present context. Hence, it must be communicated to their authors how that work is rather naive, overly sentimental, imitative of accepted styles that seek to distance themselves from political or ideological engagement — and thus to conceal something. This brings us back to dialectical materialism: they must come to understand these differences, to grasp whether technical beauty is being used to hide something, and if that is the case, what that might be. How do we interpret the social aspects of such art? Why is it important, in public exhibitions, to emphasize the communicative aspects of art and direct interaction with it? If a form of dialogue is thus established, a certain perspective of social engagement in sustaining attention to creative work becomes possible. In that way, subsequent works might be different. This is the processual nature of the development of amateurism. Ultimately, no distinction should be made between professional artists and amateurs; the difference lies in the fact that the art of the former is accessible to a specialized, interested, and selected community, while that of the latter remains local and stagnant. It does not develop, does not move in any direction, lacks interaction, mobility, communication, criticism, or interest.
In the past, such interaction did exist and amateurism had its place both within education and cultural institutions. Significant investments were made in amateurism; amateurs had their exhibitions, clubs, and workspaces within cultural centers. People could express themselves and develop their skills regardless of their primary profession. There was a communicative aspect of creativity through various manifestations, largely using social, public resources. Perhaps even those nude paintings some still produce today once relied on the works by dissident artists and times when such work was scandalous. Perhaps amateurs have wanted once to emulate bolder painters and they may believe how this is still relevant today. But why, we have to ask ourselves, are topics such as environmental pollution or corruption not considered relevant? I remember an example from the late 1970s when the workers’ newspaper of the Bor Heating Plant, Glas Toplane (The Voice of the Heating Plant), planned to publish an issue with a caricature by one of the workers printed on the front page showing a stork delivering an apartment allocation to the director. A debate ensued at the workers’ council, where the criticism focused not on the caricature’s content, but on the fact that the stork resembled a white eagle, perceived as a nationalist symbol. Of course, everyone knew what the issue really was. Workers’ newspapers of that period clearly demonstrate the existence of freedom of critical thought in informing workers through various forms of workers’ creativity—caricatures, aphorisms, poetry, and so on.